PRACTICAL POINTERS
FOR
PRIMARY CARE
ABSTRACTED MONTHLY FROM THE JOURNALS
DECEMBER 2005
HIGH PREVALENCE
OF LOW CARDIORESPIRATORY FITNESS IN ADOLESCENTS
AND ADULTS—A Risk Factor for Later Cardiovascular Disease
PERIODONTAL DISEASES—A Possible Risk
Factor For Cardiovascular Disease
A COMPARISON OF LETROZOLE (An Aromatase
Inhibitor) WITH TAMOXIFEN IN POST MENOPAUSAL WOMEN WITH EARLY BREAST CANCER
AROMATASE
INHIBITORS—A TRIUMPH OF
TRANSLATIONAL ONCOLOGY
THE METABOLIC
SYNDROME AS A PREDICTOR OF NON-ALCOHOLIC FATTY LIVER DISEASE
THE MYRIAD USES OF
BOTULINUM TOXIN
USE OF GASTRIC ACID-SUPPRESSIVE AGENTS AND THE RISK OF
COMMUNITY-ACQUIRED Clostridium difficile-ASSOCIATED
DISEASE
THE NEW VIRULENT
CLOSTRIDIUM DIFFICILE
INTENSIVE DIABETES TREATMENT LOWERS RISK OF CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE
IN PATIENTS WITH TYPE 1 DIABETES
JAMA, NEJM, BMJ, LANCET PUBLISHED
BY PRACTICAL POINTERS, INC.
ARCHIVES INTERNAL MEDICINE EDITED BY RICHARD T.
JAMES JR. MD
ANNALS
INTERNAL MEDICINE
www.practicalpointers.org
This
document is divided into two parts
1)
The HIGHLIGHTS AND EDITORIAL COMMENTS
HIGHLIGHTS condenses the contents of studies, and allows a quick
review of pertinent
points
of each article.
----------
EDITORIAL COMMENTS are the editor’s assessments of the clinical
practicality of articles
based on his long-term review of the current literature and
his 20-year publication of Practical
Pointers.
2) The main ABSTRACTS section is
designed as a reference. It presents structured summaries of the
contents of
articles in much more detail.
I hope you will find Practical Pointers interesting and helpful. The complete content of
all issues for the past 5 years can be accessed at www.practicalpointers.org
Richard T.
James Jr, M.D.
Editor/Publisher.
HIGHLIGHTS AND EDITORIAL
COMMENTS DECEMBER 2005
“Low Cardiorespiratory
Fitness Affects Approximately 1 Out Of 5 Persons Aged 12 Through 49 In The
The
National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) is a continuous,
cross-sectional, nationally representative sampling of the
non-institutionalized civilian
Participants
were adolescents age 12-19, and adults age 20-49. All were free of CVD.
All
underwent submaximal graded treadmill testing to
achieve 75% to 90% of age-predicted maximum heart rate. Estimated maximal
oxygen consumption (VO2max) by
comparing heart rate response to reference levels of submaximal
work. (Higher VO2max indicates more favorable fitness.) Cutpoints
for fitness were defined as low (< 20th percentile); moderate (20th
-59th percentiles); and high (60th and higher).
Thirty
three % of adolescents and 14% of adults had low fitness. (This represents 7.5 million adolescents in
the
More than
25% of adults reported no moderate or
vigorous physical activity in the past month.
Adults mean
body mass index (BMI) = 27. About
20% had the metabolic syndrome.
Low fitness
persons were 2 to 4 times more likely to be obese compared with those in the
moderate-high fitness groups.
The strong
association between obesity and CVD risk factors is the most striking
indication of the health burden of low fitness.
BMI and waist circumference demonstrated the most consistent association
with fitness. Mean values decreased in a nearly graded fashion with increasing
fitness. The association is already present in adolescents and young adults.
The
relationship between low fitness and cardiovascular mortality is proposed to be
mediated by the development of CVD risk factors including hypertension, diabetes,
dyslipidemia, and the metabolic syndrome.
Physical
activity training in efforts to improve fitness has been shown to lower the
likelihood of developing risk factors, independent of changes in weight.
----------
As primary care clinicians follow patients, they
should watch for any increase in BMI and abdominal girth. A change may present
an opportunity to ask about the patient’s physical activity and to encourage
intervention..
Clinician must first be able to point to their own fitness as an example.
“Could Have
A Role In The Initiation Or Progression Of Coronary Artery Disease And Stroke.”
The term
periodontal disease usually refers to the common inflammatory disorders
(gingivitis and periodontitis) that are caused by
pathogenic microflora in the biofilm
(dental plaque) that forms adjacent to the teeth every day.
Inflammation
that extends deep into
the tissues and causes loss of supporting connective tissue and alveolar bone
is termed periodontitis.
The result is formation of soft tissue pockets, or deepened crevices between
the gum and the tooth root. Severe periodontitis
results in loosening of teeth, occasional pain and discomfort, impaired
mastication, and eventually tooth loss. An estimated 13% of US adults have
moderate to severe periodontitis.
The
clinical diagnosis is based on visual and radiographic assessment.
Causes
include
1. Oral microorganisms:
The mouth
contains hundreds of species of aerobic and anaerobic bacteria (many uncharacterized)
living in symbiosis with a healthy host. These organisms grow on tooth surfaces
in biofilms. They are attached to, and densely
packed, against the tooth.
2. Tobacco:
Smokers are
much more likely to develop periodontitis. Smokeless
tobacco may also lead to gingivitis, loss of tooth support, and precancerous leucoplakia at the site of quid placement.
“In the
3.
Osteoporosis:
Osteoporosis
raises susceptibility to periodontal break down. The risk could be attenuated
by estrogen replacement therapy.
Association
with cardiovascular
disease and stroke:
Inflammation
has been implicated in the cause and pathogenesis of atherosclerosis.
“Periodontal disease could have a role in the initiation or progression of
coronary artery disease and stroke.”
Periodontitis is associated with raised systemic
concentrations of C-reactive protein, fibrinogen, and cytokines, all of which
have been causally linked to atherosclerotic-induced diseases. Periodontitis treatment has been shown to reduce serum
inflammatory markers and C-reactive protein.
In animals,
periodontal bacteria can promote platelet aggregation.
One study
reported that severe periodontitis was associated
with increased intima-media thickening.
Severe
periodontal bone loss was associated with a nearly four-fold increase in risk
for presence of carotid artery plaques.
A
meta-analysis concluded that periodontal disease was associated with a 19%
increase in the risk of
future cardiovascular disease. A 12-year study suggested that
periodontal disease and fewer teeth could be associated with a raised risk of
ischemic stroke.
Since
periodontal disease is so common, even a modest increase in risk could have
profound public-health effects.
----------
I included this review mainly to comment on the
putative relation of periodontitis with
cardiovascular disease. Although tentative, I believe the relationship should
be suspected.
Inspection of the teeth and gums should be routinely included
in the physical examination. I believe many primary care clinicians do not
regularly examine patients for periodontitis. They
defer to the dentist.
Presence of periodontitis provides an
opportunity to stress the importance of tobacco cessation.
Women may be told that osteoporosis may lead to tooth
loss.
Letrozole Was Associated With Greater Reduction In Risk Of
Recurrent Disease.
12-3 A COMPARISON OF LETROZOLE WITH TAMOXIFEN IN
POST MENOPAUSAL WOMEN WITH EARLY BREAST CANCER
Tamoxifen inhibits activity of estrogen by
competitively binding to the estrogen receptor. Aromatase
inhibitors block the conversion of androgens to estrogen, and reduce estrogen
levels in tissue and plasma.
Letrozole (Femara), a third-generation aromatase inhibitor inhibits aromatase
activity by over 99%.
This study
compared letrozole with tamoxifen
therapy in postmenopausal women with hormone-receptor- positive BC.
At
five year follow-up Letrozole (%) Tamoxifen (%)
5-y
Disease-free survival 84 81.4
Breast
cancer recurrence 10.3 13.6
Node-positive
BC survival 77.9 71.4
Node-negative
BC survival 88.7 88.7
Distant
recurrence 4.4 5.8
The
absolute % differences in favor of letrozole ranged
from 1.4% to 6.2%. The number needed to
treat with
letrozole vs tamoxifen
to benefit one patient ranged from 15 to 71. Patients who were node positive
benefited more from letrozole.
“Our study
confirms the positive results reported in other trials of letrozole
as adjuvant treatment for hormone-receptor positive breast cancer in
postmenopausal women.”
Of
particular interest was the finding of a significant reduction in the risk of
recurrences at distant sites. (Difference = 1.4% favoring letrozole).
In
postmenopausal women with endocrine-responsive BC, adjuvant treatment with letrozole, as compared with tamoxifen,
reduced risk of recurrent disease, especially at distant sites
12-4
AROMATASE INHIBITORS—A TRIUMPH OF TRANSLATIONAL ONCOLOGY
“All
evidence points to aromatase inhibitors as critically
important for improving the outcome among postmenopausal women with breast
cancer who have positive or negative lymph nodes, and who are at substantial
risk of recurrent disease. “
A Major Cause Of
Liver-Related Morbidity And Mortality
12-5 THE METABOLIC SYNDROME AS A PREDICTOR OF
NON-ALCOHOLIC FATTY LIVER DISEASE
Non-alcoholic
fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is a
major cause of liver-related morbidity and mortality. It has the potential to
progress to cirrhosis and liver failure. Non-alcoholic steatohepatitis
(NASH) is an intermediate stage of
NAFLD. NASH is characterized by hepatic steatosis,
liver cell injury, hepatic inflammation, fibrosis, and necrosis.
NAFLD is
often associated with obesity, type 2 diabetes, dyslipidemia,
and hypertension. Each of these abnormalities carries a cardiovascular disease
risk. Together they are often categorized as the insulin-resistance syndrome,
or the metabolic syndrome (The MS).
The MS is an emerging problem worldwide. Its prevalence is increasing.
This study
characterized the longitudinal relationship between The MS and NAFLD.
Prospective
observational study followed over 4400 apparently healthy Japanese men and
women age 21 to 80 who attended routine medical checkups. None abused alcohol.
None were taking drugs. None had hepatitis B or C.
The
examination included an abdominal ultrasound. The diagnosis of NAFLD was based
on ultrasound using hepato-renal contrast and liver
brightness as markers.
At
baseline, 18% of the 4000 participants had NAFLD.
NAFLD was
more common in men than in women (25% vs 10%).
During a
follow-up of 14 months, 241 men who did not
have NAFLD at baseline developed NAFLD. These men had gained weight. About 10%
of men who had NAFLD at baseline had
normal ultrasound on follow-up. These men had lost weight.
The term
NAFLD refers to a spectrum of
liver disease in the absence of significant alcohol consumption.
At the “benign” end of the spectrum, most patients with NAFLD have simple steatosis. About 10% have features of liver cell injury or
fibrosis (non-alcoholic steatohepatitis—NASH).
The
distinction between simple steatosis and NASH is
important because their natural history differs. Patients with simple steatosis have a benign prognosis, at least from the
standpoint of liver disease. Up to 20% of patients with NASH may ultimately develop advanced liver
disease.
The
prognosis of NASH-related cirrhosis is poor. About 1/3 develop liver failure or
liver-related death. Hepatocellular cancer is a
complication of NASH-related cirrhosis.
Although
only a minority of patients with NAFLD develops advanced liver disease, it is
causing alarm because of its high prevalence.
----------
The
adverse effects of
The MS extend beyond the cardiovascular system.
An important recommendation to patients with
NAFLD—even small amounts of weight loss (and loss of abdominal girth) can
reverse NAFLD. Conversely, small gains in weight can induce NAFLD.
I believe abstinence from alcohol may also be an
important recommendation. In patients with hepatitis C, abstinence has been
recommended. In addition to possible toxic effects, the tendency of alcohol to
increase caloric intake adds to risk of The MS.
If geese can be force-fed to produce fatty livers, why
cannot humans? Why not call NAFLD the “Foie Gras syndrome”?
Abdominal obesity (more specifically intra-abdominal
obesity) is emerging as a serious risk factor for cardiovascular disease.
Abdominal girth, a marker of intra-abdominal obesity, had been considered the
major criterion (of the 5) for The MS. Is the lesser risk of NAFLD in women due
to their tendency to add weight to the hips and lower extremities rather than
the abdomen? .
The “Big Belly” syndrome is a major risk factor for
both cardiovascular and liver disease.
An Important Therapeutic Agent With Widespread Applications.
12-6 THE MYRIAD USES OF BOTULINUM TOXIN
Botulinum toxin (BTx) is an important therapeutic
agent with widespread applications. It is one of the most potent neurotoxins
known. BTx derives its name from the Latin word botulus,
“sausage”. This refers to poisoning from badly preserved meat observed in the
early 19th century. BTx is a protein produced by Clostridium botulinum.
BTx targets peripheral cholinergic systems and prevents
the release of acetylcholine, blocking synaptic transmission.
Over the
past 24 years, it has proved to be remarkably successful in relieving spasms,
unwanted movements, abnormal postures, and pain associated with many disorders.
It has made it possible to control some neurological conditions that once
required systemic therapy. Double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trials have
shown that it safely and effectively resolves excessive muscle contraction in dystonia (a condition characterized by sustained twisting
and posturing movements); hemifacial spasm; and spasticity from stroke, cerebral palsy, brain trauma, and
multiple sclerosis. It has also been successful in patients with hyperhidrosis due to autonomic disorders. More recently, BTx has attracted interest in headache and pain disorders,
and for cosmetic uses.
This issue
of Annals reports effectiveness in
treatment of the pain of lateral epicondylitis
(“tennis elbow”).
C. difficile
Infection Is Becoming An Important Public Health
Issue. It May Occur Without Prior Antibiotic Use.
C. difficile is an
important cause of nosocomial diarrhea. C. difficile-associated
disease (CDAD) is also a cause of
diarrhea in the community. It has been reported that it is the 3rd
most common cause of infectious diarrhea in persons over age 75. The absolute number of CDAD cases in the
community could be significant.
Gastric
acid constitutes a major defense mechanism against ingested pathogens. Loss of
stomach acid has been associated with colonization of the normally sterile
upper gastrointestinal tract.
Suppression
of stomach acid production by proton-pump inhibitors (PPI) and histamine2-receptor blockers (H2RB) may lead to increased likelihood of CDAD.
This
case-control compared:
1)
Cases of community-acquired CDAD (n = 1233; mean age 72—no hospitalization in
the prior year), with
2)
Ten matched controls without CDAD (n = 12 330—also not hospitalized in the
prior year).
3) Determined current use of PPI and H2-RB in
both groups.
Cases were
3 times more likely than controls to have received antibiotics; 3 times more likely
to have received PPI; and 2 times more likely to have received H2RB.
Between
1994 and 2004, antibiotic prescriptions per outpatient per year declined by
about 1/3 while prescriptions for PPI increased. Community cases of C. difficile
per year rose dramatically from less than 1 case per 100 000 patients to 22 per
100 000 patients.
Antibiotic
exposure has, in the past, been considered almost a prerequisite for the
diagnosis of
CDAD. In this study, only 37% cases had received antibiotics
within the preceding 90 days. “The belief that prior antibiotic exposure is
practically a prerequisite for C. difficile infection needs to be reevaluated.”
“C. difficile -associated
disease is becoming an important public health issue.”
----------
Primary care clinicians should consider that C. difficile infection can occur without prior antibiotic use.
And that users of PPI, especially the elderly, may be
at increased risk.
Case-control studies are not definitive. This requires
confirmation.
A New Very
Virulent Strain Resistant To Fluoroquinolones.
12-8 THE NEW CLOSTRIDIUM DIFFICILE
Old
pathogens can emerge with increased virulence and challenge scientists to
explain their rebirth, and clinicians to care for patients, and infection-control
personnel to prevent their spread.
C. difficile appears to
illustrate these challenges. It already has some distinctive features. It
causes disease almost exclusively in the presence of exposure to antibiotics.1
Two
articles in this issue of NEJM describe new gene-variant strains of C. difficile
isolated from patients with C. difficile-associated disease (CDAD). The variant types were resistant to fluoroquinolones.
They produced up to 23 times more toxins A and B than some other strains. One
of the studies reported hospital incidence of CDAD of 2 per 100 admissions and
a high mortality rate, especially in the elderly. In the majority of cases, fluoroquinolones were the inducing agent.
“A more
virulent strain of C. difficile
is causing epidemic disease.”
Treatment
consists of prompt discontinuation of the implicated offending agent, and
administration of oral metronoidazole (Flagyl). Oral vancomycin should be considered in patients who do not have
a prompt response.
“Particularly important is antibiotic stewardship, with restraint in the use of implicated antimicrobial agents.”
1See the previous article. It suggests that community-acquired C. difficile-associated
disease may occur without prior antibiotic use.
Intensive Glycemic-Control
Had Long-Term Beneficial Effects In Reducing Risk Of Cardiovascular Disease.
This study
assessed whether more intensive therapy, as compared with conventional therapy,
would affect long-term incidence of macro-vascular
complications (cardiovascular disease). Type 1 diabetes (DM-1) is associated with at least a 10-fold increase in
cardiovascular disease.
The
Diabetes Control and Complications Trial (DCCT
1983-93) randomized 1441 patients with DM-1 to: 1) intensive therapy, or 2)
conventional therapy. Mean duration of 6.5 years. Mean baseline age = 27. At
baseline, subjects had no, or minimal, microvascular
disease; no hypertension; no hypercholesterolemia (by standards at the time);
and no clinical evidence of cardiovascular disease.
At the end
of 6 years, all participants were returned to their own health care providers
and the Epidemiology of Diabetes Interventions and Complications study (EDIC) began. Ninety three % of the subjects were
subsequently followed until 2005 (11 more years; total of 17 years). In the EDIC study, patients in both treatment
group then received intensive therapy, During the subsequent 11 years, there
were non-significant differences in the use of 3 or more daily injections of
insulin.
(Ie, this report compares 6
years of intensive therapy + 11 years of continued intensive therapy with 6
years of conventional therapy + 11 years of intensive therapy.)
During the
mean of 17 years, 46 cardiovascular events occurred in 31 patients in the
17-year intensive group
vs 98 events in 52 patients in those
originally assigned to conventional therapy. (0.38 vs 0.80 events per 100 patient-years.)
At
baseline, mean HbA1c was 9.1 % in both groups. At the end of DCCT (6 years), it
was 7.4% in the intensive group vs 9.1% in the conventional group. At the
end of the 17 years, mean levels were about equal in both groups (7.9% vs 7.8%). The
intensive group maintained HbA1c at a lower level; the HbA1c of those
originally in the conventional group were subsequently treated intensively and
their HbA1c fell to comparable levels.
Seventeen
continuous years of intensive therapy resulted in greater sustained benefit on
subsequent risk of cardiovascular event than the period of 6 years of
conventional therapy followed by 11 years of intensive therapy. The original
6-years of intensive therapy, begun at a younger age, produced a sustained
benefit.
The same glycemic mechanisms related to development of
micro-vascular disease may also apply to the development of arteriosclerosis.
Epidemiological evidence suggests that any elevation in glycemia,
even within the subdiabetic range, increases risk of
cardiovascular disease. This may be mediated by formation of advanced glycemic end-products
----------
The mean age at end of 17 years was 44. I would judge
the benefits would continue to accrue over a more extended period of time.
The atherosclerotic process in patients with DM-1
begins at an early age. The earlier you start intensive treatment, the better.
The results
could easily be extrapolated to patients with DM-2
The patients in the study did not meet the American
Diabetes Association goal of a HbA1c 7.0% and under. Achieving this goal is difficult. Newer insulins would likely make achieving the goal easier.
Of course, treatment should include other
interventions to reduce risk of cardiovascular disease (aspirin, statins, BP control, weight and abdominal girth control,
increased physical activity, and especially tobacco cessation. (11% to 20% of
subjects continued to smoke.)
ABSTRACTS
DECEMBER 2005
“Low Cardiorespiratory Fitness Affects Approximately 1 Out Of 5 Persons Aged
12 Through 49 In The
12-1
PREVALENCE, AND CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE CORRELATES, OF LOW
CARDIORESPIRATORY FITNESS IN ADOLESCENTS AND ADULTS
Physical
inactivity and poor cardiorespiratory fitness (ie, fitness) are associated with higher morbidity and
mortality from all causes, including cardiovascular disease (CVD) and cancer. A recent large
case-control study attributed 12% of myocardial infarctions to physical
inactivity.
Our society
is becoming increasingly less physically active.
This study
describes the prevalence of low fitness in the
Conclusion: Low fitness was associated with increased
prevalence of CVD risk factors.
STUDY
1.
The National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) is a continuous,
cross-sectional, nationally representative sampling of the
non-institutionalized civilian
2.
Participants were adolescents (n = 3110) age 12-19, and adults (n = 2205) age
20-49. All were free of CVD. None had existing medical conditions, physical
limitations, or abnormal hemodynamic parameters.
3.
All underwent submaximal graded treadmill testing to
achieve 75% to 90% of age-predicted maximum heart rate. Estimated maximal
oxygen consumption (VO2max) by
correlating heart rate response to reference levels of submaximal
work. (Higher VO2max indicates more favorable fitness.)
(The determination of fitness was objective
[treadmill testing]. This
is a strength of the study.)
4.
Cutpoints were defined as low (< 20th
percentile); moderate (20th -59th percentiles); and high
(60th and higher).
5.
Main outcome measures: 1) low fitness (defined using percentile cut points of estimated
VO2max). and 2) other CVD risk factors.
RESULTS
1. Adolescents Adults
Low fitness 33% 14%
(This represents 7.5 million adolescents
in the
2.
More than 25% of adults reported no
moderate or vigorous physical activity in the past month.
3.
Adults mean BMI = 27. About 20% had the metabolic syndrome.
4.
Low fitness persons were 2 to 4 times more likely to be obese compared with
those in the moderate-high fitness groups
5.
Prevalence of low fitness was higher in adult females, blacks, and
Mexican-Americans.
6.
In all age groups, BMI and waist circumference were inversely related to low
fitness.
7.
Total cholesterol and systolic BP were higher in the low fitness groups, and
HDL-cholesterol was lower.
DISCUSSION
1.
“Low cardiorespiratory fitness affects approximately
1 out of 5 persons aged 12 through 49 in the
2.
The most striking indication of the health burden of
low fitness is the strong association between obesity and CVD risk factors. BMI
and waist circumference demonstrated the most consistent association with
fitness. Mean values decreased in a nearly graded fashion with increasing
fitness. The association is already present in adolescents and young adults.
3.
Although adolescents are not generally considered at risk for having clinical
CVD events in the short term, the development of risk factors during
adolescence and young adulthood sets the stage for heart disease in the middle
and older ages.
4.
The relationship between low fitness and cardiovascular mortality is proposed
to be mediated by the development of CVD risk factors including hypertension,
diabetes, dyslipidemia, and the metabolic syndrome.
5.
Physical activity training in efforts to improve fitness has been shown to
lower the likelihood of developing risk factors, independent of changes in
weight.
6.
“Obesity and overweight could be described as the seminal public health problem
today.” The burgeoning obesity epidemic is the first sign of the trend of
increasing morbidity and mortality from chronic diseases.
7.
These data likely represent an underestimate of the true prevalence of low
fitness in the population.
8.
Historical evidence from the campaign to educate about the dangers of cigarette
smoking indicates that education efforts, particularly among youth, can retard
and reverse negative health behaviors.
CONCLUSION
Low
fitness is a prevalent and important public health problem. It is associated
with increased prevalence of CVD risk factors.
JAMA
“Could Have A Role In The Initiation Or Progression Of
Coronary Artery Disease And Stroke.”
12-2
PERIODONTAL DISEASES
The term
periodontal disease usually refers to the common inflammatory disorders
(gingivitis and periodontitis) that are caused by
pathogenic microflora in the biofilm
(dental plaque) that forms adjacent to the teeth every day.
Gingivitis is the mildest form of periodontal
disease. It is highly prevalent and is readily reversible by simple effective
oral hygiene. Inflammation that extends deep into the tissues and causes loss of
supporting connective tissue and alveolar bone is termed periodontitis. The result is
formation of soft tissue pockets, or deepened crevices between the gum and the
tooth root. Severe periodontitis results in loosening
of teeth, occasional pain and discomfort, impaired mastication, and eventually
tooth loss. An estimated 13% of US adults have moderate to severe periodontitis.
CAUSE:
1. Oral microorganisms:
The mouth
contains hundreds of species of aerobic and anaerobic bacteria (many
uncharacterized) living in symbiosis with a healthy host. These organisms grow
on tooth surfaces in biofilms. They are attached to,
and densely packed, against the tooth.
2. Tobacco:
Smokers are
much more likely to develop periodontitis. Smokeless
tobacco may also lead to gingivitis, loss of tooth support, and precancerous leucoplakia at the site of quid placement.
“In the
3. Nutrition:
Extensive
epidemiological studies have failed to show an effect of minor hypovitaminoses on periodontal disease.
4. Osteoporosis:
Evidence
indicates that osteoporosis raises susceptibility to periodontal break down.
The risk could be attenuated by estrogen replacement therapy.
5. Diabetes:
Patients
with well-controlled diabetes do not
seem to be at increased risk. Those with poorly controlled diabetes are at
raised risk.
PATHOGENESIS:
Although
bacteria are necessary for periodontal disease to take place, a susceptible
host is also needed.
An immune
response to the plaque bacteria results in destruction of the periodontium. The host response is essentially protective, but both
hypo-responsiveness and hyper-responsiveness of certain pathways can result in
enhanced tissue destruction. Both the host and the bacteria release proteolyic
enzymes which break down tissue.
After all
oral hygiene procedures (including tooth brushing) are ceased, the biofilm begins to develop within 24 hours and causes
gingivitis in 2 to 3 weeks. Thorough cleaning returns gums to a healthy
condition within about 1 week.
Once a
periodontal pocket forms and becomes filled with bacteria, the situation
becomes largely irreversible. Gingival epithelium proliferates to line the
pocket and even if treatment resolves the inflammation and some bone and
connective tissue are regenerated, complete restoration of the lost tooth
support is impossible.
DIAGNOSIS:
The
clinical diagnosis is based on visual and radiographic assessment.
Mild
bleeding during tooth brushing is often a result of chronic gingivitis. It is
usually only a minor annoyance.
Chronic periodontitis is usually asymptomatic until so severe that
teeth shift and loosen. Patients may have periodontal abscesses and halitosis.
ASSOCIATIONS WITH SYSTEMIC DISEASES:
A. Pregnancy:
Several
prospective cohort studies have reported a link between poor periodontal health
and increased risk of complications of pregnancy—preterm birth, low birth
weight, and preeclampsia.
B. Cardiovascular disease and
stroke:
Inflammation
has been implicated in the cause and pathogenesis of atherosclerosis.
“Periodontal disease could have a role in the initiation or progression of
coronary artery disease and stroke.”
Periodontitis is associated with raised systemic
concentrations of C-reactive protein, fibrinogen, and cytokines, all of which
have been causally linked to atherosclerotic-induced diseases. Periodontitis treatment has been shown to reduce serum
inflammatory markers and C-reactive protein.
In animals,
periodontal bacteria can promote platelet aggregation.
One study
reported that severe periodontitis was associated
with increased intima-media thickening.
Severe
periodontal bone loss was associated with a nearly four-fold increase in risk
for presence of
carotid artery plaques.
A
meta-analysis concluded that periodontal disease was associated with a 19%
increase in the risk of
future cardiovascular disease. A 12-year study suggested that
periodontal disease and fewer teeth could be associated with a raised risk of
ischemic stroke.
Since
periodontal disease is so common, even a modest increase in risk could have
profound public-health effects.
C. Pulmonary disease:
Various
pulmonary infections have been associated with periodontal disease. There are
reports that potential respiratory pathogens that cause pneumonia colonize the
mouth of high-risk patients in intensive care units.
Preliminary
studies indicate that oral hygiene with mechanical or antiseptic rinses can
reduce the rate of respiratory infections in patients living in institutions.
PREVENTION AND TREATMENT:
Regular
tooth cleaning can maintain the biofilm mass at an
amount compatible with gingival health. “Unfortunately, few individuals achieve
this, and exhortations to the public to clean teeth more thoroughly are
generally ineffective in public health care.”
Control of
the biofilm by professionally administered oral
hygiene can slow or stop periodontitis and tooth loss
by many years.
Tooth
brushing and use of dental floss to remove plaque are the most common ways of
removing biofilm. They are effective if used
daily. They require motivation.
Mouthwashes
and toothpastes containing antibacterial drugs have been used as adjuncts. They can reduce biofilm and are generally not associated with emergence of
resistant microbes. Used as adjuncts to
cleaning methods, they can reduce gingivitis. Their role in preventing or
treating periodontitis has not been established.
Tobacco
use should be stopped.
Antibiotics:
There is insufficient evidence that microbial assessment can improve treatment
outcomes. A wide variety of antibiotics has been used, either alone or in
combination with standard therapy. Limited data exists regarding their effect
when used alone. Use runs the risk of adverse drug reactions and increased
selection of resistant organisms. “Systemic antibiotics should be used only in
conjunction with mechanical debridement.” They can
provide the greatest benefit to patients who do not respond to debridement alone, or who have fever and lymphadenopathy.
Lancet
Letrozole Was Associated With Greater Reduction In Risk Of
Recurrent Disease.
12-3 A
COMPARISON OF LETROZOLE WITH TAMOXIFEN IN POST MENOPAUSAL WOMEN WITH EARLY
BREAST CANCER
Among women
with hormone-receptor-positive breast cancer (BC), tamoxifen (Nolvadex) reduces risk of breast
cancer (BC) recurrence by 47%, and
the risk of death by 26% About half of the women relapse.
Tamoxifen inhibits activity of estrogen by
competitively binding to the estrogen receptor. Aromatase
inhibitors block the conversion of androgens to estrogen, and reduce estrogen
levels in tissue and plasma.
Third
generation aromatase inhibitors:
Letrozole (Femara a
non-steroidal—inhibits aromatase activity by over
99%)
Anastrozole (non-steroidal—inhibits aromatase activity by 97%)
Exemestane (steroidal—inhibits aromatase activity by 98%)
This study
compared letrozole with tamoxifen
therapy in postmenopausal women with hormone-receptor- positive BC
Conclusion: Letrozole was
associated with greater reduction in risk of recurrent disease.
STUDY
1.
Randomized, double-blind study entered over 8000 postmenopausal women (mean age
61).
2.
All had operable invasive BC positive for estrogen receptors, progesterone
receptors, or both. In all, the primary surgery had clear margins. None had
evidence of metastatic disease.
3.
Nodal status: negative in 57%; positive in 41%.
4.
Estrogen-receptor positive and progesterone + receptor positive (63%).
Estrogen-receptor
positive and progesterone-receptor negative (20%);
Estrogen
receptor negative and progesterone-receptor positive (2%).
5.
Randomized to:
A. Letrozole (2.5 mg daily) alone for 5 years.
Letrozole
alone for 2 years followed with tamoxifen alone for 3
years.
B. Tamoxifen (20 mg daily) alone for 5 years.
Tamoxifen alone
for 2 years followed by letrozole alone for 3 years.
5.
Primary end-points included: 1)
disease-free survival—time from randomization to the first event ending
disease-free survival: 2) recurrence at
local, regional, or distant sites; and 3) a new invasive cancer in the
opposite breast.
6.
Follow-up for up to 5 years. Median follow-up = 26 months.
RESULTS
1. Five year follow-up Letrozole
(%) Tamoxifen (%)
both groups (n = 4003) both
groups (n = 4007)
5-y
Disease-free survival 84 81.4
Breast
cancer recurrence 10.3 13.6
Node-positive
BC survival 77.9 71.4
Node-negative
BC survival 88.7 88.7
Distant
recurrence 4.4 5.8
2. The absolute % differences in
favor of letrozole ranged from 1.4% to 6.2%. The number needed to treat with letrozole vs tamoxifen
to benefit one patient ranged from 15 to 71.
3. Benefit from letrozole-alone
was also greater than benefit from tamoxifen alone. (Data not shown.)
4. Benefit from letrozole
was as evident in patients with progesterone-receptor positive status as with
estrogen- receptor positive
status.
5. Safety:
A.
More patients in the letrozole groups reported at
least one protocol-specified adverse event of any severity (73% vs 63%).
B.
The number of patients with life-threatening or fatal adverse events was
similar in both groups (1.7%).
C.
Adverse effects Letrozole (%) Tamoxifen (%)
Cardiac
event 4.1 3.8
Vaginal
bleeding 3.3 6.6
Hot
flashes 33.5 38
Night
sweats 13.9 16.2
Fracture
5.7 4.0
Arthralgia 20.3 12.3
D.
Cholesterol: Both groups were associated with reductions—letrozole -1.8%;
tamoxifen
-14%. Hypercholesterolemia
more common in the letrozole groups (44% vs 19%).
DISCUSSION
1.
“Our study confirms the positive results reported in other trials of letrozole as adjuvant treatment
for hormone-receptor positive breast cancer in postmenopausal women.”
2.
Of particular interest was the finding of a significant reduction in the risk
of recurrences at distant sites. (Difference = 1.4% favoring letrozole.)
3.
Patients who were node positive benefited more from letrozole.
Node negative patients did not benefit.
4.
The American Society of Clinical Oncology states that information is
insufficient to determine the effect of
aromatase inhibitors of cardiovascular disease,
especially coronary disease.
CONCLUSION
In
postmenopausal women with endocrine-responsive BC, adjuvant treatment with letrozole, as compared with tamoxifen,
reduced risk of recurrent disease, especially at distant sites.
NEJM
Study supposed by Novartis.
12-4 AROMATASE INHIBITORS—A
TRIUMPH OF TRANSLATIONAL ONCLOLGY
(This editorial comments and expands on the preceding
study.)
Great
strides have been made in the diagnosis and treatment of early-stage breast
cancer (BC).
Both
screening and adjuvant (postoperative) therapy have increased survival. The
benefit occurs in all subgroups of patients, regardless of the presence or
absence of tumor cells in the draining lymph nodes. Benefit extends to women
who are premenopausal and postmenopausal, and to
those with estrogen-receptor-negative as well as estrogen-receptor-positive
tumors.
BC consists
of a heterogeneous group of cancers. They are now being classified into
subgroups in order to delineate distinct characteristics and targets that will
lead to tailored therapies.
A
randomized trial reported in this issue of NEJM concerned postmenopausal women
with early-stage BC. The aromatase inhibitor letrozole (Fermara) was compared with the estrogen-receptor blocker tamoxifen (Nolvadex). The findings validated the results of previous
studies—letrozole was associated with a greater
reduction in the incidence of relapse.
The
incidence of both distant recurrence and contralateral
BC was reduced. The benefit of letrozole was greatest in women who had positive nodes.
Five other
trials have evaluated aromatase inhibitors alone, or
with various combinations of tamoxifen for various
lengths of time. All have reported more favorable outcomes with letrozole.
Questions
remain: What is the optimal duration of
therapy? Should tamoxifen
or aromatase inhibitor be given first? Is sequential treatment optimal? Which aromatase
inhibitor is better? Are aromatase
inhibitors beneficial for premenopausal women after
ovarian ablation? Are they beneficial in women whose tumors are
progesterone-receptor positive? Progesterone-receptor negative?
Estrogen is
synthesized from androstenedione and testosterone.
The enzyme aromatase facilitates the synthesis. Aromatase inhibitors block the conversion to estrogen
almost completely.
Unlike tamoxifen, aromatase inhibitors
are not associated with an increased risk of thromboembolism
or uterine cancer. But the incidence of serious cardiac events was more common
in women given letrozole.
“All
evidence points to aromatase inhibitors as critically
important for improving the outcome among postmenopausal women with breast
cancer who have positive or negative lymph nodes, and who are at substantial
risk of recurrent disease. “
NEJM
A Major Cause Of
Liver-Related Morbidity And Mortality
12-5 THE
METABOLIC SYNDROME AS A PREDICTOR OF NON-ALCOHOLIC FATTY LIVER DISEASE
Non-alcoholic
fatty liver disese (NAFLD) is a major cause of liver-related morbidity and mortality.
It has the potential to progress to cirrhosis and liver failure. Non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH)
is an intermediate stage of NAFLD. NASH is characterized by hepatic steatosis, liver cell injury, hepatic inflammation,
fibrosis, and necrosis. It resembles alcohol-induced liver disease, but it
occurs in people who do not abuse alcohol.
NAFLD is
often associated with obesity, type 2 diabetes, dyslipidemia,
and hypertension. Each of these abnormalities carries a cardiovascular disease
risk. Together they are often categorized as the insulin-resistance syndrome,
or the metabolic syndrome (The MS).
The MS is an emerging problem worldwide. Its prevalence is increasing.
The MS
consists of 5 variables: 1) high waist
circumference, 2) elevated serum triglycerides, 3) reduced HDL-cholesterol, 4)
elevated BP, and 5) elevated fasting plasma glucose.
This study
characterized the longitudinal relationship between The MS and NAFLD.
Conclusion: The MS is a strong predictor of NAFLD.
STUDY
1. Prospective observational study followed over 4400
apparently healthy Japanese men and women age 21 to 80 who attended routine
medical checkups. None abused alcohol. None were taking drugs. None had
hepatitis B or C.
2. The examination included an abdominal ultrasound. The
diagnosis of NAFLD was based on ultrasound using hepato-renal
contrast and liver brightness as markers.
3. Correlated NAFLD with prevalence of The MS (3, 4, or 5
indicators to be present to diagnose The MS):
1) Abdominal
obesity (circumference > 102 cm in men and > 88 cm in women).
2) Triglycerides
> 150 mg/dL.
3) HDL-cholesterol
< 40 for men and < 50 for women.
4) BP > 130/85.
5) Fasting glucose
> 110 mg/dL.
(Because waist
measurement was not available for the entire cohort, the investigators
substituted a BMI of 25 or more for all participants as an index of obesity.
This cutpoint has been proposed to diagnose obesity
in Asian people.)
RESULTS
1. At baseline, 18% of the 4000 participants had NAFLD.
NAFLD was more
common in men than in women (25% vs 10%).
In men, the
prevalence of 3 or more criteria for The MS was more common in those who had
NAFLD vs
those who did not have NAFLD (40% vs 8% in women).
2. During a follow-up of 14 months, 241 men who did not have NAFLD at baseline developed
NAFLD. These men had gained weight.
About 10% of men who had NAFLD
at baseline had normal ultrasound on follow-up These men had lost weight.
3. Among subjects who did not have NAFLD at baseline, those who
met the criteria for The MS were more likely to develop NAFLD during follow-up.
(Odds ratio = 4.0)
DISCUSSION
1. The MS was a strong risk factor for nonalcoholic fatty
liver disease in apparently healthy Japanese men and women.
2. The MS is highly predictive of insulin resistance. Insulin resistance may play a pivotal role in
the pathophysiology of NAFLD.
3. The investigators
state that ultrasonography of the liver may lead to
an incorrect diagnosis of NAFLD in 10% to 30%. US cannot distinguish between steatohepatitis and simple steatosis.
4. Generalization to non-Japanese is uncertain.
CONCLUSION
Japanese
persons with The MS had increased risk of developing NAFLD.
Development
and regression of NAFLD may occur in a substantial number of people with modest
weight changes.
Annals Int
Med November 15, 2005; 143: 722-28
Original investigation, first author Masahide Hamaguchi,
Asahi University Murakami Memorial Hospital, Gifu, Japan.
An
editorial in this issue of the Annals (pp 753-54), first author Elizabeth E
Powell,
The term
NAFLD refers to a spectrum of
liver disease in the absence of significant alcohol consumption.
At the “benign” end of the spectrum, most patients with NAFLD have simple steatosis. About 10% have features of liver cell injury or
fibrosis (non-alcoholic steatohepatitis—NASH).
The
distinction between simple steatosis and NASH is
important because their natural history differs. Patients with simple steatosis have a benign prognosis, at least from the
standpoint of liver disease. Up to 20% of patients with NASH may ultimately develop advanced liver
disease.
The
prognosis of NASH-related cirrhosis is poor. About 1/3 develop liver failure or
liver-related death. Hepatocellular cancer is a
complication of NASH-related cirrhosis.
Although
only a minority of patients with NAFLD develops advanced liver disease, it is
causing alarm because of the high prevalence of NAFLD.
NAFLD can
develop with very small increases in body weight. Small decreases in weight can cause
regression of NAFLD. Lifestyle modification is the principle management
strategy.
Increased
waist circumference (abdominal obesity) is more closely associated with The MS
than is BMI.
Once cirrhosis
develops, fat and other histological features of steatohepatitis
may regress, leaving inactive micronodular
cirrhosis. It has been suggested that
many cases previously regarded as cryptogenic cirrhosis may represent “burnt
out” NASH.
Abdominal
ultrasound is an imperfect tool to diagnose NAFLD. Without biopsy, it cannot be
determined which patients have NAFLD or which have NASH. Liver
function tests have not been helpful for diagnosis. We rely mainly on clinical
factors. Biopsy is the gold standard for diagnosis.
An Important Therapeutic Agent With Widespread Applications.
12-6
THE MYRIAD USES OF BOTULINUM TOXIN
Botulinum toxin (BTx) is an important therapeutic
agent with widespread applications. It is one of the most potent neurotoxins
known. BTx derives its name from the Latin word botulus,
“sausage”. This refers to poisoning from badly preserved meat observed in the
early 19th century. BTx is a protein produced by Clostridium botulinum.
BTx targets peripheral cholinergic systems and prevents the
release of acetylcholine, blocking synaptic transmission.
It was
first used therapeutically in the 1970s to treat strabismus. Over the past 24
years, it has proved to be remarkably successful in relieving spasms, unwanted
movements, abnormal postures, and pain associated with many disorders. It has
made it possible to control some neurological conditions that once required
systemic therapy. Double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trials have shown
that it safely and effectively resolves excessive muscle contraction in dystonia (a condition characterized by sustained twisting
and posturing movements); hemifacial spasm; and spasticity from stroke, cerebral palsy, brain trauma, and
multiple sclerosis. It has also been successful in patients with hyperhidrosis due to autonomic disorders. More recently, BTx has attracted interest in headache and pain disorders,
and for cosmetic uses.
Long-term
studies report that it continues to be safe and effective after repeated use
for 15 years.
The effect
of one injection may last for several months, but it is self-limited. It has few side effects—the main one being
unwanted weakness in the injected muscles or adjacent muscles. The effects on
muscle tone and involuntary movements usually last longer than the weakness does.
Excessive
weakness can be avoided by using low doses, and by electromyography-guided
injections.
Electromyographic guidance is helpful for accurately
localizing muscles, particularly for limb conditions such as writer’s cramp.
BTx has also been reported to be useful to treat pain
through yet unknown pain-relieving mechanisms.
This issue of Annals reports
effectiveness in treatment of the pain of lateral epicondylitis
(“tennis elbow”)1.
Compared with placebo injections, BTx significantly
relieved pain at 4 and 12 weeks. “These findings are promising because BTx injections are less harmful than other therapies for
lateral epicondylitis, such as corticosteroids or
surgery.”
The number
of applications is expanding. Currently, physicians should consider BTx of patients who have focused involuntary movements.
Annals Int
Med
1 “Treatment of Lateral Epicondylitis
with Botulinum Toxin” Annals Int
Med December 6, 2005; 143: 793-97
original investigation, first author Shiu Man
Wong, Chinese University of Hong Kong, China.
C. difficile Infection Is Becoming An
Important Public Health Issue. It May Occur Without Prior Antibiotic
Use.
12-7 USE OF GASTRIC
ACID-SUPPRESSIVE AGENTS AND THE RISK OF COMMUNITY-ACQUIRED Clostridium difficile- ASSOCIATED DISEASE
C. difficile
is an important cause of nosocomial diarrhea. C. difficile-associated
disease (CDAD) is also a cause of
diarrhea in the community. It has been reported as the 3rd most
common cause of infectious diarrhea in persons over age 75. The absolute number of CDAD cases in the
community could be significant.
Gastric
acid constitutes a major defense mechanism against ingested pathogens. Loss of
stomach acid has been associated with colonization of the normally sterile
upper gastrointestinal tract.
Suppression
of stomach acid production by proton-pump inhibitors (PPI) and histamine2-receptor blockers (H2RB) may lead to increased likelihood of CDAD.
This
study determined whether gastric acid-suppressive agents increase risk of CDAD
in the community.
Conclusion: These agents, especially PPI, were associated
with increased risk of community-acquired CDAD.
STUDY
1. Case-control study compared:
1)
Cases of community-acquired CDAD (n = 1233; mean age 72—no hospitalization in
the prior year), with
2)
Ten matched controls without CDAD (n = 12 330—also not hospitalized in the
prior year).
2. Determined current use of
antibiotics, PPI and H2-RB in both groups.
RESULTS
1. Comparison Cases
Controls:
Antibiotics 37% 13%
PPI 23% 8%
H2RB 8% 4%
3. Cases were 3 times more likely
than controls to have received antibiotics; 3 times more likely to have
received PPI; and 2 times more likely to have received H2RB.
4. An unexpected finding: cases were 1.3 times more likely to have
received NSAIDs excluding aspirin.
(The investigators state this requires further study.)
5 Between 1994 and 2004:
A.
Antibiotic prescriptions per outpatient per year declined by about 1/3 while
prescriptions for PPI increased.
B.
Community cases of C. difficile
per year rose dramatically from less than 1 case per 100 000 patients to
22 per 100 000 patients.
DISCUSSION
1. This increased risk of CDAD
associated with PPI (vs
H2RB) may be related to the greater degree of
gastric acid suppression by PPI.
2. Decreased gastric acidity is a
risk factor for other infectious diarrheal diseases
(traveler’s diarrhea,
salmonellosis, cholera).
3. Antibiotic exposure has, in the
past, been considered almost a prerequisite for the diagnosis of
CDAD. In this study, only 37% cases had received antibiotics
within the preceding 90 days. “The belief that prior antibiotic exposure is
practically a prerequisite for C. difficile infection needs to be reevaluated.”
4. Acid-suppressive agents are
among the most frequently prescribed medications. Their use by the public
is increasing. While the overall rate of CDAD is lower than in
hospital settings, incidence in the community appears to be increasing
significantly. This has occurred in the face of data suggesting that
outpatient antibiotic use is declining.
5. “C. difficile -associated disease is
becoming an important public health issue.”
CONCLUSION
Use
of acid-suppressive drugs, particularly PPIs, is
associated with increased risk of community-acquired
C. difficile-associated
diarrhea.
JAMA
A New Very Virulent Strain Resistant To Fluoroquinolones.
12-8 THE NEW CLOSTRIDIUM DIFFICILE
Old
pathogens can emerge with increased virulence and challenge scientists to
explain their rebirth, and clinicians to care for patients, and infection-control
personnel to prevent their spread.
C. difficile appears to
illustrate these challenges. It already has some distinctive features: it
causes disease almost exclusively in the presence of exposure to antibiotics1; it is the
only anaerobe that poses a nosocomial risk; and it
produces a toxin in vivo only in the colon.
About 3% of
healthy adults and up to 40% of hospitalized patients are colonized with C. difficile.
In healthy persons, the organism is inactive in the spore form. It is assumed
that a perturbation of the competing flora promotes a conversion to the
vegetative forms that then replicate and produce toxins.
The history
of antibiotic-associated colitis (AAC)
began with a multitude of reports early in the antibiotic era. At first, AAC was
generally attributed to S aureus. C. difficile
was reported as the cause in 1978. Within 3 years, toxins A and B were
described and the cytotoxin assay became the standard
diagnostic test.
The
characteristic pathological finding is pseudomembranous
colitis. Clinical studies indicate that almost any antibiotic with an
antibacterial spectrum could cause this complication. Oral vancomycin
became the standard treatment.
Over the
past 2 decades, C. difficile
has become the most commonly recognized microbial cause of nosocomial
diarrhea. This reflects the high rates of antibiotic use in hospitals. The most
commonly implicated agent in the 1970s was clindamycin;
in the 1980s, cephalosporins. Recently, fluoroquinolones have played a prominent role.
A 13-year study
of C. difficile-associated
diarrhea reported the rate increased by a factor of 4 during this period. The
disease became increasingly severe.
Major risk factors were age over 65, and receipt of fluoroquinolones.
Two
articles in this issue of NEJM 2,3 describe new gene-variant strains of C. difficile
isolated from patients with C. difficile-associated disease (CDAD). The variant types were resistant to fluoroquinolones.
They produced up to 23 times more toxins A and B than some other strains. One
of the studies reported hospital incidence of CDAD of 2 per 100 admissions and
a high mortality rate, especially in the elderly. In the majority of cases, fluoroquinolones were the inducing agent.
“A more
virulent strain of C. difficile
is causing epidemic disease at selected locations, and is associated with more
frequent and more severe disease, as indicated by higher rates of toxic megacolon, leukemoid reaction,
shock, requirement for colectomy, and death.”
Treatment
consists of prompt discontinuation of the implicated offending agent, and
administration of oral metronoidazole (Flagyl) Oral vancomycin
should be considered in patients who do not have a prompt response.
“Particularly important is antibiotic stewardship, with restraint in the use of implicated antimicrobial agents.”
NEJM
1 See the
previous article. It suggests that community-acquired C. difficile-associated
disease may occur without prior antibiotic use.
2 “An Epidemic, Toxin Gene-Variant Strain of Clostridium difficile”
(pp 2433-41), first author L Clifford McDonald, Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention,
3 “A Predominantly Clonal
Multi-Institutional Outbreak of Clostridium
difficile-Associated Diarrhea with High Morbidity
and Mortality.” (pp 2422-41) first author Vivian
G Loo,
Intensive Glycemic-Control Had Long-Term Beneficial Effects In Reducing
Risk Of Cardiovascular Disease.
12-9 INTENSIVE
DIABETES TREATMENT AND CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN PATIENTS WITH TYPE 1
DIABETES The Diabetes Control and
Complications Trial/Epidemiology of Diabetes Interventions and Complications
Study (DCCT/EDIC)
Hyperglycemia
appears to play a central role in the pathophysiology
of diabetes complications.
Intensive
diabetes therapy aimed at near normoglycemia reduces
risk of micro-vascular complications
of type 1 diabetes (DM-1)—retinopathy,
nephropathy, and neuropathy..
This study
assessed whether more intensive therapy, as compared with conventional therapy,
would affect long-term incidence of macro-vascular
complications (cardiovascular disease). DM-1 is associated with at least a
10-fold increase in cardiovascular disease.
Conclusion: Intensive glycemic-control
had long-term beneficial effects in reducing risk of cardiovascular disease.
STUDY
1.
The Diabetes Control and Complications Trial (DCCT 1983-93) randomized 1441
patients with DM-1 to: 1) intensive therapy, or 2) conventional therapy. Mean
duration of 6.5 years. Mean baseline age = 27. At baseline, subjects had no, or
minimal, microvascular disease; no hypertension; no
hypercholesterolemia (by standards at the time); and no clinical evidence of
cardiovascular disease.
2.
Intensive therapy consisted of 3 or more daily insulin injections, or treatment
with an insulin pump. Doses were adjusted based on at least 4 daily
self-monitored blood glucose measurements. Glucose goals were 70 to 120 mg/dL before meals, and less than 180
after meals. The goal for HbA1c was less than 6.05%.
3.
Conventional therapy had no glucose goals beyond those needed to prevent
symptoms of hyperglycemia and
hypoglycemia, and consisted of 1 or 2 daily injections of insulin.
4.
During the 6-years of the
DCCT trial, fewer cardiovascular events (non-fatal myocardial
infarction, stroke, death from cardiovascular disease, angina, need for
coronary revascularization) occurred in the intensive group. The numbers of
events were small in this relatively young cohort. This precluded definitive
conclusions. Consequently, the trial was extended.
5.
At the end of 6 years, all participants were returned to their own health-care
providers, and the EDIC study began. Ninety three % of the subjects were
subsequently followed until 2005 (11 more years; total of 17 years). Patients in both treatment groups then
received intensive therapy. During the subsequent 11 years, there were
non-significant differences in the use of 3 or more daily injections of
insulin.
(Ie, this report compares 6
years of intensive therapy + 11 years of continued intensive therapy with 6
years of conventional therapy + 11 years of intensive therapy.)
RESULTS
1.
During the mean of 17 years, 46 cardiovascular events occurred in 31 patients
in the 17 year intensive group vs 98 events in 52
patients in those originally assigned to conventional therapy. (0.38 vs 0.80 events per 100
patient-years.)
2.
At baseline mean HbA1c was 9.1 % in both groups. At
the end of DCCT (6 years), it was 7.4% in the intensive group vs 9.1% in the conventional group. At the
end of the 17 years, mean levels were about equal in both groups (7.9% vs 7.8%). The
intensive group maintained HbA1c at a lower level. The HbA1c of those
originally in the conventional group, after being referred back to their
original health-care providers were treated intensively and their HbA1c fell to
comparable levels.
DISCUSSION
1.
Seventeen continuous years of intensive therapy resulted in greater sustained
benefit on risk of cardiovascular event than the period of 6 years of
conventional therapy followed by 11 years of intensive therapy. (The 6 years of
intensive therapy, begun at a younger age, had a sustained benefit.) The pathophysiological mechanisms for the prolonged effects of
early intervention are not clear. The authors refer to it as “metabolic
memory”.
2.
The same glycemic mechanisms related to development
of micro-vascular disease may also apply to the development of
arteriosclerosis. Epidemiological evidence suggests that any elevation in glycemia, even within the subdiabetic
range, increases risk of cardiovascular disease. This may be mediated by
formation of advanced glycemic end-products
3.
Intensive therapy should be implemented as early as possible.
CONCLUSION
Intensive
diabetes therapy has long-term benefits on the risk of cardiovascular disease
in patients with type 1 diabetes.
JAMA